Tuesday 11 September 2007

'The Cider House Rules" by John Irving


First published: 1985
600 pages (paperback)

My third "Irving" after Hotel New Hampshire and Garp. Can't really say which one is the best, but the Cider House Rules definitely have the potential of being one of the best books by Irving. It's so full of likable characters, all with their faults and virtues, and the feeling of time passing throughout the book is so real that it's hard to accept parting with it at the end. You wanna know and continue to know those people for real. At least that's something that I felt when reading the Cider House Rules and that I also remember from reading his other books.
More than once, while reading it, I thought something like "damnit, he really IS a good writer". It's not just his characters but also the detailed background information, for instance about obstetrical procedures of that time or about picking and pressing apples on a large scale, that make the story so believable, even though everything still is a bit "larger than life" (at least my life is not THAT interesting, hope that's not just me...).
So if you haven't read anything by Irving yet, it's high time you did! And if for some reason you DON'T like it, please tell me, I'd be really curious as to why that is.
Although there are maybe four or five major characters, Dr.Larch - at least to me - is by far the most interesting, even though I guess Homer Wells is supposed to be the main hero. Dr. Larch is the doctor in charge at the orphanarium in the tiny ex-logging town of St. Clouds. He also is the historian of the place and does not hesitate to throw in a little fiction every now and then whenever it seems necessary. He is a fervent abortionist (which was illegal at that time, the novel covers the time from the 20ies to the 50ies) as well as an ether addict. Homer, starting out as one of the orphans born at St.Cloud's, at last, after several unsuccessful attempts at finding new foster homes, becomes a permanent resident there - and something like a son to Dr. Larch, who teaches him all about his trade (obstetrical procedures, that is).
Besides the two adorable nurses Edna and Angela there is one other long-term resident at the orphanarium: Melony, a big, violent girl who provides Homer with his first sexual experiences and later on makes it her life's purpose to search for Homer, after he finally gets "adopted", as a young man, by a young wealthy couple his own age whom he befriends after they had an abortion. The couple, Candy and Wally, belong to a family in the apple business. They show Homer life outside the orphanarium and he decides to stay. Things become a little more complicated, however, as Homer and Candy fall in love with each other...
The main themes of the book are abortion (the different positions towards it weighed off against each other) and orphans (Charles Dickens' David Copperfield reappears throughout the book), although there is much more in it. It's funny and serious and definitely gripping.

1 comment:

Unknown said...

Long time since I read that... it seems to me that you bypassed the story of Melony; didn't she end up with a female lover? Anyways, John Irving certainly is a gifted story teller, with a knack for the unusual. I particularly love his strange eclectic characters who play so well in tune. Garp, for example, who is passed around by his fellow pupils as he is vertically so very compact... or his teacher, who then demands that he "... come down from there immediately". I remember that I very much enjoyed the Cider House Rules, and that the story left me numb for a couple of days... kinda like waking up after heavy dreams. Certainly worth a re-read.